Welcome to our Brita vs PUR faucet filter comparison guide. In this guide, you’ll learn everything you need to know about these two faucet filters before you decide which is the superior option for your home.
Choosing the best faucet filter is quite tricky because all of them come with their own set of drawbacks. It’s our goal to give you the best chance of avoiding any potential pitfalls and choosing a reliable filter that requires little to no maintenance.
Brita and PUR are two of the most well-known home water filtration brands, and two of the most trustworthy names. Both companies manufacture NSF/ANSI certified filters, which is not always easy to find in the loosely-regulated water filter space.
In this guide, we provide a head-to-head comparison chart, replacement filter info, compare current PUR vs Brita faucet filter reviews, and share our winner.
Let’s start with a spec comparison.
Brita vs PUR Faucet Filter Spec Comparison
- As part of our review process, we run a search on the Water Quality Association (WQA) website to verify NSF/ANSI certifications. We want to point out that PUR uses an independent lab and does not appear on the WQA website. Brita faucet filters are certified by the WQA under NSF/ANSI Standards 42, 53, 401.
- There’s no mention of PUR using BPA-Free materials in its faucet filters, while Brita clearly states its parts are BPA-Free.
In this section, we’ll go over the available replacement filters for both systems:
PUR Basic (1, 2, 3, 4, 5 Packs)
PUR MineralClear (1, 2, 3, 4, 6 Packs)
Brita Faucet Replacement Filter (2 & 3 Packs)
Replacement Filter Notes
- Both systems include the first filter.
- Brita offers filters in both chrome and white finishes to match the model you choose.
- PUR offers two different filter models. The MineralClear filter has an added mineral stage to enhance the flavor of your filtered water. The good news is the MineralClear filter only costs a dollar or so more, and it removes the same contaminants as the Basic filter.
- Brita has 1-Click Filter Replacement that makes changing filters a breeze.
- 3-packs of Brita and PUR replacement faucet filters cost roughly the same while a 2-pack of Brita filters is more affordable.
- Brita filters are labeled BPA-Free, and PUR filters are not.
- Both filters remove lead, chlorine, and most other common water contaminants.
- Both filters do no remove fluoride.
Now that we have the basics out of the way, let’s see what current owners are saying about their Brita and PUR faucet filters.
Current PUR vs Brita Faucet Filter Reviews
An integral part of our review and comparison process is a close look at the current reviews to see what owners are saying. At this point, we know both of these faucet filters use the same types of filtration media to remove a wide range of contaminants, but how do they perform?
Brita Faucet Filter Reviews
- The taste reports impressed us. Most Brita faucet filter owners agree that the filtered water tastes great.
- On the flip side of the coin, there are users having problems with water flow. One owner said the most they can get to come out is a slow drip. Another disgruntled owner ended up with a leaking filter until it eventually broke off, which led to a geyser in his kitchen.
- Coffee drinkers approve of the filtered water for making their morning coffee, particularly for their grumpy hubbies.
- Reviews concerning the functionality of the filter life indicator are mixed. Some people love it, and a handful of others said it stopped working.
- One person advised avoiding switching from tap water to filtered water while the water is running. It’s better to make the switch while the faucet is closed.
- One happy owner loves the convenience of the faucet filter over the Brita pitcher because they no longer need to wait on the pitcher to fill pots for cooking.
- Plants and pets enjoy Brita filtered water.
- One person owned PUR before Brita and prefers the new Brita filter over PUR.
- Overall, the reviews are somewhat offputting, with a large number of one-star reviews. However, we investigated mostly current reviews, and there are a lot more positive reviews than negative. We believe improper installation caused a good chunk of the problems people reported.
PUR Faucet Filter Reviews
- A Lousiana resident is thrilled with theirs. They use it for cooking, coffee, pets, and watering flowers with great results. They also reported that it does a great job of transforming the yucky Lousiana water into tasty filtered water.
- The main issue with this filter appears to be durability. The PUR filter definitely delivers on taste and filtration, but there are numerous reports of units lasting for less than a year.
- Several owners noted that installation is easy-peasy.
- Leak reports are more prominent than we’d like to see. Leaks are generally the most common problem with faucet filters, and it’s one of the reasons we don’t recommend faucet filters as a first choice.
- There’s a Bluetooth version of the PUR faucet filter that allows you to track your water consumption and the filter life. The reviews are a mixed bag for this feature, and overall, we don’t recommend it unless you’re mighty fond of the idea. Most people said it’s difficult to connect through the app, or they stopped using it after the first couple of weeks.
- Similar to Brita, when the PUR filter works, it’s not a bad filter, just don’t expect it to last for years.
Brita or PUR faucet which is better? The winner is…
After finishing our analysis, we chose:
Why did we choose Brita?
There are three main reasons why we chose the Brita faucet filter over PUR:
- The first reason is Brita is BPA-Free. We couldn’t find any mention of PUR being BPA-Free, and we feel as though if their faucet filters were BPA-Free, PUR would make it known on its packaging and/or product description.
- The second reason is Brita filters are listed on the WQA website. PUR uses an independent lab, which isn’t as trustworthy as appearing on the WQA website.
- If one thing is for sure, neither of these faucet filters is built to last. They’ll last you about the same period, and the Brita system & filters are more affordable. Why pay more for PUR? That’s the question I asked myself.
Neither Brita’s or PUR’s faucet filters impressed us. The one thing we do like about Brita is the NSF/ANSI certifications on the WQA website. If the company strived to construct better housing for its faucet filter, the system could be a winner.
Perhaps Brita is okay with selling a system they know will break because people will always come back for more. This could be the same case for PUR since the companies are two of the most recognizable names.
What did you think of our Brita vs PUR faucet filter comparison? If you’d like us to add anything, we’d love to hear from you in the comments section below.
Stay tuned for more great reviews, cheers!