Tyent USA - Water For Wellness

Welcome to our comprehensive Berkey Shower Filter review and Propur vs Berkey shower filter comparison. In this guide, you’ll learn everything you need to know about the Berkey before you buy and decide if your money is best spent elsewhere. This month is shower filter review month here at AWMS, and we’re overflowing with shower filtration knowledge.

We know how hard and confusing it can be to track down a shower filter that removes chloramine and fluoride. As part of our review, we’ll answer whether the Big Berkey Shower Filter removes these common water contaminants.

Both chloramine and fluoride removal are tricky for shower filters due to the elevated flow rate and hot temperature of the water. There are few shower filters on the market that get the job done.

Let’s start by exploring the core features of the Berkey, then move onto current Berkey shower filter reviews to see if owners are happy. Feel free to use the Table of Contents below to jump between sections.

Berkey Shower Filter Overview

Model Features & Highlights

Berkey Shower Filter (KDSF)

berkey shower filter review

  •  Removes up to 95% of Chlorine 
  • Filter Life: 20,000 gallons or 1 year
  • Filter Media: High-Purity Blend of Zinc, Calcium, and Copper (very similar to Sprite Chlorgon)
  • Warranty: Exclusive Berkey Lifetime Warranty
  • Dimensions: 5″ Long x 4″ Diameter (Filter Housing)
  • Highlights: One of the best chlorine shower filters currently on the market | The unmatched lifetime warranty | Included backwash attachment for easy maintenance (great for well water) | Extra-long filter life | Available w/ or w/o showerhead | A top-rated shower filter of 2019 | Reduces scale and ideal for iron-rich water | Great for reversing chlorine damage to hair and skin
View Price at Amazon >>

Current Berkey Shower Filter Reviews

As part of our analysis for each product we review, we investigate current reviews to identify positive and negative trends. We’ve found that shower filters all come with their own set of complaints, however, the Berkey has significantly fewer negative reviews than other competing shower filters on the market.

Here’s what we concluded after analyzing current Berkey shower filter reviews:

  • The Berkey is a great choice for people fighting iron bacteria in well water. An iron bacteria problem often leads to reddish stains in your tub and funky odors while showering. The Berkey is a top choice for reducing the funk and preventing those unsightly stains.
  • Owners recommend backwashing the filter, and we do as well. One of the greatest advantages of the Berkey filter is the included backflush attachment that makes backwashing easy. Backwashing extends the life of the filter, prevents clogging, and ensures you get the full 20,000-gallon life out of your filter.
  • If you’re suffering from dry itchy skin due to chlorinated municipal water, the Berkey filter may be the answer to your problem. Dandruff and eczema sufferers are also finding relief.
  • The Berkey is effective for preventing/reducing limescale.
  • The most common complaints (and there aren’t many) are broken filter housings or leaking. Of all the shower filters we’ve reviewed, Berkey has one of the lowest numbers of broken filter housing complaints, and trust me, they all have them.
  • If you’re dealing with noxious chlorine odor, the Berkey does a great job of removing it.
  • A lot of women are noticing softer, more manageable hair after showering.
  • Overall, the Berkey shower filter has glowing reviews, and the positive current reviews far outweigh the negative ones.

Read Current Reviews at Amazon

Does the Berkey shower filter remove chloramine?

The Berkey shower filter does not contain filter media for chloramine removal. To make a long story short, the Berkey shower filter does not remove chloramine.

We recommend our list of best Vitamin C shower filters and our Pelican Premium Shower Filter review for better options. Chloramine removal requires Vitamin C filtration or a special type of activated carbon to achieve significant reduction rates.

We also recommend reading how to test for chloramine.

Does the Berkey shower filter remove fluoride?

Fluoride removal with a  shower filter is even trickier than chloramine removal. Fluoride removal typically requires an activated alumina filter, reverse osmosis membrane, or selective ion-exchange resin for adequate removal.

The only shower filter we’ve yet to see that removes fluoride is the Propur shower filter, which we’ll take a closer look at in the next section.

Final Answer: The Berkey shower filter does not remove fluoride.

Propur Shower Filter vs Berkey

 

 

berkey shower filter review

propur vs berkey shower filter
Model Berkey (KDSF) Propur ProMax
Filter Life 20,000 gallons or 1 year 6-9 Months
Filter Media High-Purity Blend of Zinc, Calcium, and Copper Multi-Stage Granular Activated Carbon
Chlorine Reduction % 95% 57.1% at .9 mg/l concentration
Removes Chloramines? N/A Yes (71% at .9 mg/l concentration)
Removes Fluoride? N/A Yes (48.2% at .9 mg/l concentration)
Warranty Berkey Lifetime Warranty 9-Month Warranty & 30-Day Money-Back Guarantee
Price View Berkey Price at Amazon View Propur Price at Amazon

Who Wins?

Here are several scenarios where one filter is the clear winner over the other:

  • If you want a filter that removes over 90% of chlorine, the Berkey shower filter is the clear winner. According to the Propur lab test results, the Propur reduces chlorine by just 57.1% at .9 mg/l concentration.
  • The shower filters cost roughly the same, yet the Berkey shower filter has a longer filter life which equals lower annual replacement filter costs for the Berkey.
  • If you want to purchase a shower filter that’s proven to remove chloramines and fluoride, then the Propur shower filter is the clear choice for you.
  • The Propur shower filter was independently tested to meet NSF/ANSI Standards 42 and 53, while Berkey does not provide lab test results for its filter.
Conclusion
Both filters have mostly positive reviews written by satisfied owners. We trust both brands, and we feel as though the decision comes down to the three points above.
We recommend testing your water for chloramines or calling your water provider to conclude whether they treat your water with chloramines. If you need to remove chloramines, choose the Propur. If you have chlorine only, then the Berkey is the better choice.

Our Berkey Shower Filter Review

Now, it’s time for our two cents. We’ve reviewed a long list of shower filters, and we’re confident that the Berkey is one of the best currently on the market. However, no product is perfect, and we strive to make our reviews as fair as possible.

I broke our review into two parts: our likes and our dislikes.

Dislikes

  • We would like to see Berkey post lab test results to prove a 95% chlorine reduction rate and to see what else the filter removes. We also prefer to buy water filters that are tested to meet or exceed NSF/ANSI Standards. If we didn’t already trust the Berkey brand, we would be more skeptical about this filter.
  • The Berkey shower filter costs more than a Sprite shower filter and uses essentially the same type of filtration media. We also noticed that Tyent’s shower filter uses Sprite’s Chlorgon filtration media. Sprite is one of the original shower filter manufacturers that came well before Berkey. The drawback is the Sprite reviews aren’t as positive as the Berkey reviews. We recommend our Sprite shower filter review to get a better perspective.

Likes

  • All shower filters come with their own sets of complaints, and the Berkey shower filter has a smaller number of negative reviews compared to most other shower filters on the market.
  • People are experiencing the benefits of chlorine reduction, e.g, softer skin, shinier hair, dandruff relief, eczema relief, and more.
  • We love the included backflush attachment. We believe all shower filters should include one because gunk will inevitably build at the filter’s entry point. Backwashing the filter pushes out all the gunk and ensures that the filter does its job for the life of the filter.
  • The extra-long filter life – A lot of filters on the market need to be replaced every couple of months, and one of the major drawbacks of owning a Vitamin C shower filter is the constant filter changes.
  • The redox media & calcium sulfite combination in the Berkey shower filter is a powerful blend and the chosen combination for shower water filtration and hot water. For this reason, we believe Berkey is in accordance with NSF/ANSI Standard 177 for chlorine reduction, despite not stating it.
  • Lastly, Berkey is the only company we’ve seen that offers a lifetime warranty on its filter.

Final Score: 8.5/10

berkey shower filter review

Buy Now at Amazon!

Bottom Line

After reading through the current Berkey shower filter reviews and expanding upon our own analysis for this filter, we’re confident that it’s one of the best currently on the market. It’s one of our top-rated shower filters for well water and has found its way onto several of our Top 5 lists.

Buy this filter with the confidence that you’re buying a top-notch shower filter from a trustworthy company. When you invest in a shower filter, you invest in your health and appearance. Why deal with the damaging effects of chlorine on your hair, skin, and nails when there’s an easy solution?

What did you think of our Berkey shower filter review? If there’s anything you’d like us to add, let us know in the comments below.

10 Amazing Alkaline Herbs & Spices to Dramatically Boost Your Health

10 Amazing Alkaline Herbs and Spices to Dramatically Boost Your Health!

Sign up now to get instant access to our exclusive list of amazing alkaline herbs and spices plus where to find them!

You're all set!